Home | Copyright | Four Ways Copyright Law Hurts Visual Artists
Copyright

Four Ways Copyright Law Hurts Visual Artists

Copyright Law

As both lawyers and artists, Art Law Journal contributors stay abreast of developments to copyright laws, including the ways the existing laws could harm artists. But laws that were designed to protect artistry and the freedom of creative expression can often be interpreted as benefiting corporations and big business instead of individual artists, which in turn creates a monopoly that significantly weakens the profitability artists have over their work. Existing copyright laws seem overly burdensome on ordinary citizens, yet alarmingly simple to avoid for major social media companies like Facebook and Instagram. With so much blatant, illegal file-sharing happening across the internet, it seems that artists and creatives should have someone to hold responsible for the appropriation of their creative work.

Possibly even more troubling, sometimes the people that artists and creatives hire to help them take care of defending copyright lawsuits engage in practices that wind up being detrimental to the people they’re supposed to represent, while also harming the copyright law model as a whole. In recent years, shady practices surrounding copyright laws have become more widespread, and many wonder whether these practices are harming the business of upholding and defending copyrights for lawyers and artists alike.

While it’s unlikely that copyright laws will change significantly in the coming years, its important for artists to be aware of the ways in which the current system can sometimes fail you. Read on to learn five crucial points for avoiding any trouble – and getting compensated for your own troubles – with copyright law.

Copyright law is no-fault

Copyright law gives artists and makers a powerful set of rights which they can use to ensure their profitability, but being careless with other people’s creative work can often result in some serious repercussions for the artist. A copyright holder has the exclusive right to reproduce the work, prepare derivative works based upon the original work, distribute copies to the public, publicly perform the work, publicly display the work, and digitally transmit sound recordings of the work. These rights are exclusive, meaning that anyone who takes it upon themselves to share your work or use it in some unauthorized way has infringed on your copyright, and is, therefore, liable to you for monetary damages.

Sounds great, right? Kind of. Copyright is a two-way street, and it’s also no fault: just like anyone who infringes on your copyright would be held liable for damages, so would you. And whether or not you “knew” that the copyright belonged to someone else is entirely irrelevant. This rule can be especially dangerous for artists or creative who blog – use someone else’s image without permission, and you could find yourself in trouble. Unfortunately, the fact that copyright law is no-fault is often unfair: for example, even if you legitimately purchased a photo from a stock photo site, if it’s found that the image was purchased by the company from someone who had stolen the photo, both you and the stock photo site are liable for damages.

Copyright lawyers sometimes go straight to settlement without looking at the facts

Lawsuits against file sharers are commonplace in the United States, but its assumed that the attorneys who defend artists and creatives who inadvertently shared copyrighted material are doing so in the best interests of their clients. But in a recently published article by Torrent Freak, well-known intellectual property attorney, Robert Cashman expressed his concerns over a trend wherein defense attorneys partner to create “settlement factories.” for copyright law cases.  These attorneys essentially settle cases without making any effort to determine whether or not their client is actually at fault.

These attorneys attract leads using Google AdWords and then convince respondents to work with them to settle their claims. These attorneys can offer their services cheaply because they’re running a volume-based business, wherein the goal is to attract and convince as many customers as possible to go straight to settlement instead of trying to defend any claims. Once they’ve attracted the customer, they spend only a few minutes reviewing the case, because they’ve already prearranged with the plaintiff attorney to settle claims for a certain amount using a boilerplate contract. All too often, this results in higher settlement amounts which sets a precedent and drives up costs for anyone who might be faced with a copyright claim.

If you’re faced with a copyright lawsuit, it’s best to go with someone you know. Contact Art Law Journal or the EFF for trustworthy attorneys.

DMCA safe harbor keeps social media giants virtually blameless

We spend a lot of time talking about the DMCA safe harbor here on Art Law Journal, but that’s because its blanket protection for major social media sites with deep pockets is pretty astounding. Under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, internet service providers are protected from copyright liability if they meet specific requirements, including whether they passively engage users, whether they have a direct financial benefit from the copyrighted work, and whether or not they knew the material was infringing. If they end up finding the material is in fact protected by copyright, and then they must follow a framework for responding to the copyright owner’s request to take the content down.

So for instance, YouTube is often protected from being held liable for copyright infringement because it doesn’t charge its users a subscription fee, it doesn’t review or promote the content they post, and it responds promptly to takedown notices. But there are various issues with this kind of model. First, it puts an overwhelming burden on the owner of the copyright, since neither the website nor the poster is required to verify the origination of the content. Second, the takedown notice only delays the potential for a copyright lawsuit, since the infringing poster can respond with a put-back notice, without having to prove that they have the right to post and distribute that content. This means the only way a copyright holder can regain ownership of their work product is through a lawsuit, which may be prohibitive due to legal fees and court costs.

Unlike musicians, artists don’t receive royalties for their work

Royalties allow musicians who own the copyright in their work to benefit from royalties every single time their song is used in a film, performed in play, or heard on the radio. It’s easily tracked via organizations like ASCAP and allows musicians to benefit from their creative works even long after they’re dead. But such a scheme does not exist for artists – once their artwork is sold, the artist receives no further income or royalties. The artist will expend resources and time on not just improving their art, but also promoting their brand.  If through hard work and determination, the artist gains notoriety and popularity, the value of their artwork will increase. However, the artist only receives a benefit from new works.  Any increase in the value of previous works benefits only the collector while the artists receive no resale royalties.  A while ago we discussed the possibility of copyright law reform that would allow artists to claim royalties on their work. Under that structure, an artist would be entitled to a 3-5% gain every time the work is re-sold.

It’s hard to say whether or not there’s a way to remedy this situation without some serious reform to the rules, but a good solution might be to track and maintain a relationship with the collectors of your works, so that you can document the work’s increase in value and later lobby for a larger profit.

About the author

Nicole Martinez

Nicole is a writer and law school graduate with a dedicated focus and passion for the arts, and a particular interest in Latin American art and history. Nicole has extensive experience working with art galleries and museums in Buenos Aires and Miami, and explores cultural landscapes across the Americas through her writing.

You can e-mail Nicole at [email protected]

1 Comment

Click here to post a comment

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • An Interview With Syd Carpenter

    Sculptor Syd Carpenter on working as an ornamental gardener, Fellowship programs and the challenges of being a Philadelphia artist.The post An Interview With Syd Carpenter appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Mastering Your Pitch Presentation

    Your best ideas are only as good as how well you can sell them, and mastering the art of the pitch presentation takes time, research, and devotion.The post Mastering Your Pitch Presentation appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How to Land Top Freelance Gigs

    From cementing your personal branding to building a digital portfolio highlighting your best work, here's how you land the top freelance gigs available.The post How to Land Top Freelance Gigs appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Bill Carroll: Career Advice from the Artist, Professor & EFA Studios Director

    Pratt Institute professor and EFA director Bill Carroll talks about his career trajectory, lessons from the art market, and the fundamental shifts he's made in the pursuit of his art.The post Bill Carroll: Career Advice from the Artist, Professor […]

  • Develop an Art Catalog, Sell More Work

    From keeping an art archive to keep your studio organized to developing a sleek art catalog for sales, artists should incorporate an organizational routine if they're looking to grow their business.The post Develop an Art Catalog, Sell More Work […]

  • How to Create the Perfect Pitch Deck

    When preparing to present your services to a potential client, what should go into your pitch deck? From services offered to payment schedules, here's how to create a deck that lands the gig.The post How to Create the Perfect Pitch Deck appeared […]

  • How Museum Hotels Like 21c Serve Art to Their Local Communities

    Museum hotels like 21c are finding new ways to engage with their local art communities. Here's how artists can work collaboratively with this innovative new concept.The post How Museum Hotels Like 21c Serve Art to Their Local Communities appeared […]

  • How to Host a Meetup for Local Artists

    Organizing an art meetup is an excellent way to build community. We sit down with the founders of successful initiatives like the Portland Artist Network and the Rural America Contemporary Art Group.The post How to Host a Meetup for Local Artists […]

  • AR as Visual Narrative: In Conversation with Todd Berreth

    NC State University professor Todd Berreth discusses his evolution as an artist and technologist, with a focus on exploring visual narrative within an AR framework.The post AR as Visual Narrative: In Conversation with Todd Berreth appeared first on […]

  • How This New Startup is Elevating AR Creatives

    As the prevalence of augmented reality technology continues to rise, more creatives look to incorporate it into their practice. Companies like Poplar are looking to support AR creatives.The post How This New Startup is Elevating AR Creatives […]

  • Ahol Sniffs Glue on Retail Partnerships and Never Selling Out

    Artist Ahol Sniffs Glue shares insights on managing your brand, taking on retail partnerships and embracing the hustle.The post Ahol Sniffs Glue on Retail Partnerships and Never Selling Out appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • What is Participatory Design in the Arts?

    Introducing principles of participatory design and participatory art into your work can create a more personal experience for your audience, while also promoting repeated viewings for new experiences.The post What is Participatory Design in the […]

  • Let’s Get Virtual! VR Innovations Bridge Fine Arts & Technology

    How is VR and AR affecting the fine arts sector? In a conversation with [email protected] radio, Grace Cho and Todd Berreth discuss emerging trends in VR art.The post Let’s Get Virtual! VR Innovations Bridge Fine Arts & Technology appeared first on […]

  • Mi-Kyoung Lee on Developing a Practice Far From Home

    Born in South Korea, Philadelphia-based artist Mi-Kyoung Lee weaves fiber and plastic to create ethereal sculptures that meditate on labor and domesticity.The post Mi-Kyoung Lee on Developing a Practice Far From Home appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How an Artist and Musician Collab Can Help Double Your Audience

    From album cover art to costumes and set designs, pairing an artist and musician for an ongoing collaboration is a wonderful way to expand both their networks.The post How an Artist and Musician Collab Can Help Double Your Audience appeared first on […]

  • Why Artists Should Still Use Handwritten Notes

    Looking for a way to connect with your private collectors? Handwritten notes remain a charming gesture that makes a lasting impression.The post Why Artists Should Still Use Handwritten Notes appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Is The End of the Art Fair in Sight?

    Is the art fair model dead? The advent of online art sales and the high cost of participation has the art world wondering whether more fairs equals more problems.The post Is The End of the Art Fair in Sight? appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Ditch the Pricey Rent and Run a Pop Up Gallery Instead

    Throughout history, artists have held a pop up gallery exhibition as an intrepid way of drawing attention to their work. Here's why you shouldn't wait for a gallery to come knocking.The post Ditch the Pricey Rent and Run a Pop Up Gallery Instead […]

  • Exploring Alternative Art Spaces to Show Your Work

    Galleries aren't the only places looking to show art. Alternative art spaces like cafes and music venues can help you expand your influence and your market.The post Exploring Alternative Art Spaces to Show Your Work appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • NYAA Grad Matthew Alfonso Durante on Taking Risks

    Artrepreneur sits down with NYAA grad Matthew Alfonso Durante and talk about rural Wisconsin, coming to New York and comic books.The post NYAA Grad Matthew Alfonso Durante on Taking Risks appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]