Home | Business | Hershey Sues Pot-Infused Chocolate Company
Business Trademarks

Hershey Sues Pot-Infused Chocolate Company

Hershey lawsuit

A word of caution to startup businesses: don’t play-off another company’s graphic designs; they can be very protective of their intellectual property. I know it’s tempting to use well-known images to jump-start your sales, but it’ll probably end up badly. Case in point; Pot-infused candy maker, TinctureBelle, thought using variations of recognizable Hershey product packaging would be an appropriate marketing strategy. Hershey Co., however, thought differently, suing the small Colorado company for trademark infringement over four of the company’s candies; Ganja Joy, Hasheath, Hashees and Dabby Patty, which Hershey’s claims are too similar to Hershey’s Almond Joy, Heath, Reese’s peanut butter cups and York peppermint patty candies, respectively.

TinctureBelle’s alleged packaging appropriation is not surprising, as many people tend to view trademarks as applying only to names, logos or symbols. However, Trademarks, however, also encompass non-traditional characteristics, such as shapes, sounds, smells, tastes and textures. While it is true that these non-traditional types of trademarks are the most difficult when applying for Federal registration, unregistered trademarks still receive a good amount of statutory and common-law protection.

Trademark law, specifically through the Lanham Act, ensures that consumers are not confused as to the makers of similar products or services due to similarities in their branding. Also, the Lanham Act prohibits false designation of origin, false or misleading descriptions or representations and false advertising.

TinctureBelle’s alleged packaging appropriation is not surprising, as many people tend to view trademarks as applying only to names, logos or symbols.

Given the potential for problems down the road, it is critical for new businesses or businesses with new product lines, to have an Intellectual Property attorney review their strategic and marketing plans to understand the potential risks. It doesn’t make any sense for a business to move ahead without both protecting their own intellectual property and getting clearance in their use. Imagine implementing a marketing plan, creating package designs, developing a website, buying domain names, hiring a public relations firm, and even purchasing business cards and stationary, only to receive as cease-and-desist letter fro the Trademark holder.

That may be what happened with TinctureBelle. Their product packaging looks so similar to Hershey’s product packaging, that Hershey’s sued them on the belief that consumers, including children, might think they are Hershey products. Based on the look of the packaging, and aggressive nature with which Hershey tends to defend its intellectual property, a good IP attorney probably would have advised against the package designs. Perhaps TinctureBelle was aware of the risks and still chose to move ahead; either way, they are now fighting a major corporation with lots of money and legal resources at their disposal.

Nevertheless, it is still up to Hershey to prove the trademark infringement. Courts look at several factors when deciding whether there might be a likelihood of confusion between two products or services. Known as the “Polaroid Factors,” they are derived from a 1961 Supreme Court case of Polaroid Corp. v. Polarad Elecs. Corp. Each of the factors weighs against each other; none being determinative, but some carrying more weight than others. The factors include:

  • Strength of the mark; the more distinctive the mark, the more likely there will be confusion.
  • Similarity of the marks, from the standard of a normal observer.
  • Similarity of the products or services. If the packaging held playing cards, there would be much less confusion than for candy products.
  • Likelihood that the mark’s owner will move into the infringing products market. TinctureBelle is a food product, so it is more likely Hershey would enter the pot-infusion market than automobile parts or some other non-food related product line.
  • Evidence of actual confusion. Proof of consumer confusion is not required, but it helps.
  • Sophistication of the buyers. The less sophisticated the purchaser, the more likely the confusion.
  • Quality of the infringing products or services. Lesser quality products cause the consumer more harm than if the product was better than the original.

There are numerous ways of proving or disproving the “Polaroid factors,” so TinctureBelle is not out of the game yet, although the fight will be a tough one. Hershey will likely ask the court to impose an injunction, which stops TinctureBelle from selling any of the four products pending the outcome of the case. Unless the outcome is almost assuredly in favor of Hershey, the court will be hesitant to impose such a damaging action before TinctureBelle has been able to present their defense. If they can get past that hurdle, TinctureBelle will have some breathing room. One thing that can be sure though, cases like this take a long time to play out.

About the author

Steve Schlackman

As a photographer and Patent Attorney with a background in marketing, Steve has a unique perspective on art and law. Should you have any questions on Intellectual Property contact him at [email protected] His photography can be seen online at Fotofilosophy.com or on display at the Emmanuel Fremin Gallery in New York City.

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

{{Privy:Embed campaign=133844}}

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • Developing an Artist Network Can Lead to New Opportunities

    Developing an artist network builds camaraderie within your local community and enhances the possibility of landing new opportunities.The post Developing an Artist Network Can Lead to New Opportunities appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • A Primer for Self Publishing in the Arts

    Whether self-publishing materials on your artistic practice or extending your creative work to digital publications, we’ve selected expert advice to guide you in producing written materials.The post A Primer for Self Publishing in the Arts […]

  • What ArtTactic’s Art & Finance Report Reveals About the Art Market

    The Deloitte and ArtTactic Art & Finance Report offers some keen insights into the state of the art market. Discover which findings spell good news for working artists.The post What ArtTactic’s Art & Finance Report Reveals About the […]

  • Inside the Evolution of Art Finance

    How does an art collection turn into wealth? Companies like Athena Art Finance Corp. and Art Money are making it easier to cash in on this billion-dollar industry.The post Inside the Evolution of Art Finance appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • What Every Artist Should Know About Shipping and Insuring Artwork

    Shipping and insuring artwork is a necessary step if you're transporting your work to exhibition spaces or collector's homes. Here's how to choose the best options for your needs.The post What Every Artist Should Know About Shipping and Insuring […]

  • The Essential Guide to Photographing Your Artwork

    For the working artist striving to make a sale or land that open call, being able to present your work in professional images is key. We offer an exhaustive guide to photographing your artwork.The post The Essential Guide to Photographing Your […]

  • Stefan Draschan’s Captivating Photography Series Border Obsession

    Photographer Stefan Draschan painstakingly observes everyday life. The photographer tells Artrepreneur that his newfound success as an emerging photographer was born from a desire to kick bad habits.The post Stefan Draschan’s Captivating […]

  • An Art Entrepreneur’s Guide to the Freelance Side Hustle

    Freelancing while working full-time is a great way to build your creative business. Artrepreneur breaks down the side hustle for the budding freelance creative business or art entrepreneur.The post An Art Entrepreneur’s Guide to the Freelance […]

  • How to Implement a Powerful Art Marketing Strategy

    How can artists implement an art marketing plan that’s both measurable and effective? Artrepreneur reviews some proven marketing strategies for artists.The post How to Implement a Powerful Art Marketing Strategy appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • A Guide to Eliminating Artist Debt and Sticking to a Budget

    The average working artist faces student loans and other debt. We ask several financial experts how they coach artists through managing artist debt while budgeting for their creative business.The post A Guide to Eliminating Artist Debt and Sticking […]